Managing your finances can be one of the most challenging aspects of adult life. Whether you’re just starting out in your career or you’re well on your way to achieving your financial goals, one question often looms large: Should I focus on paying off debt, or should I start investing?
It’s a question that many people face, and the answer isn’t always straightforward. The decision can significantly impact your financial future, and getting it right is crucial for building wealth, reducing stress, and achieving your long-term goals. In this post, we’ll dive deep into both sides of the argument—paying off debt first versus investing—and help you find the strategy that’s right for you.
Understanding High-Interest Debt: The Case for Paying Off Debt First
Before we can weigh the benefits of investing versus paying off debt, it’s essential to understand the burden that high-interest debt places on your finances.
High-interest debt—such as credit card debt—can be a significant obstacle to achieving financial freedom. As of 2024, the average American household carries around $8,000 in credit card debt, with interest rates on those cards often over 20%. With such high rates, the amount of interest you’re paying can quickly spiral out of control if you’re only making the minimum payments.
Let’s say, for instance, that you have $10,000 in credit card debt with an 18% interest rate. If you only make the minimum payments, it could take you over 25 years to pay off that debt. During that time, you’ll end up paying more than $15,000 in interest alone—more than the original balance of the debt.
Why High-Interest Debt Is Dangerous
The reason high-interest debt is so dangerous is that it works against you. Every dollar you’re paying in interest is a dollar that’s not going towards building your wealth. Over 40% of U.S. households carry some form of credit card debt, and the average household with credit card debt pays about $1,000 a year in interest alone.
Not only does this interest drain your financial resources, but it also adds a significant amount of stress to your life. According to the American Psychological Association, nearly 70% of Americans report that debt is a significant source of stress in their lives. This stress isn’t just financial—it can affect your mental health, relationships, and even your physical well-being.
The Case for Paying Off Debt First
Given the burden of high-interest debt, you might be wondering whether it makes sense to prioritize paying it off before you start investing. And in many cases, the answer is yes.
Paying off high-interest debt is like getting a guaranteed return on your money. If you pay off a credit card with an 18% interest rate, you’re essentially getting an 18% return on your payment. That’s a risk-free return that’s nearly impossible to find in today’s market.
But it’s not just about the numbers. There’s also a significant psychological benefit to paying off debt. Being debt-free gives you peace of mind—one less thing to worry about. According to a study by Northwestern Mutual, people with significant debt are twice as likely to report high levels of financial stress compared to those with low or no debt. By eliminating your debt, you’re not just improving your financial situation; you’re also improving your overall quality of life.
In addition, paying off debt can free up your cash flow for other financial goals. Imagine what you could do with an extra few hundred dollars each month—whether it’s investing more aggressively, building an emergency fund, or saving for a major purchase like a home or car.
Improving Your Credit Score
Another benefit of paying off debt is that it can improve your credit score. Credit utilization—the percentage of your available credit that you’re using—accounts for 30% of your FICO score. Reducing your credit card balances by paying off debt can significantly boost your credit score, which in turn can save you thousands of dollars in interest on future loans, lower your insurance premiums, and even help you secure better rental terms if you’re looking to move.
The Case for Investing While Paying Off Debt
While paying off debt first has clear benefits, there’s also a strong case to be made for investing while you’re still carrying some debt. The key here is balance—finding the right mix of debt repayment and investing that works for your unique situation.
When you invest, your money has the potential to grow over time, thanks to the power of compounding. Historically, the stock market has returned an average of 7-10% per year, depending on the period and the specific investments you choose. If you start investing early, your money has more time to grow, which can make a big difference in your long-term wealth.
The Power of Compounding
Let’s say you start investing $300 a month in a portfolio that averages an 8% return. After 10 years, you could have over $50,000. Meanwhile, if you’re only paying the minimums on a $10,000 credit card debt with an 18% interest rate, your balance may not drop significantly, but your investments could have grown substantially.
This is where the concept of opportunity cost comes into play. Opportunity cost refers to the potential gains you miss out on when you choose one option over another. In this case, if you focus solely on paying off debt, you might miss out on the early years of compounding growth that could significantly boost your investment portfolio over time.
According to a report by Morningstar, delaying investment by just five years can result in a 15-20% reduction in potential retirement savings. By investing while paying off debt, you’re ensuring that your money is working for you in more ways than one.
Balancing Debt and Investing
Of course, investing while you still have debt comes with risks. The biggest concern is the interest on your debt, especially if it’s high, like with credit cards. If your debt carries an interest rate under 7%, it might be worth considering investing at the same time. That’s because, on average, the stock market has historically outperformed these rates.
If you’re considering this approach, it’s important to run the numbers and make sure you’re comfortable with the risks.
For example, let’s say you’re considering adding $100 extra per month to your debt payment while also investing in your 401(k) or IRA. By doing both, you’re not just eliminating debt faster; you’re also starting to build that investment portfolio that will pay off big time down the road.
Debt Avalanche vs. Debt Snowball: Two Popular Strategies for Paying Off Debt
When it comes to paying off debt, two popular strategies often come up: the Debt Avalanche method and the Debt Snowball method. Both approaches are effective, but they cater to different mindsets and financial situations. Let’s break down each one:
Debt Avalanche Method: A Mathematical Approach
The Debt Avalanche method focuses on minimizing the total amount of interest you pay over time. Here’s how it works:
- List Your Debts by Interest Rate: Organize your debts from the highest interest rate to the lowest.
- Make Minimum Payments on All Debts: Continue making the minimum payments on all your debts.
- Apply Extra Payments to the Highest-Interest Debt: Any extra money you have goes towards the debt with the highest interest rate.
- Move Down the List: Once the highest-interest debt is paid off, move on to the next one on the list, applying extra payments there.
The primary benefit of the Debt Avalanche method is that it saves you the most money in interest over time. If you’re motivated by numbers and want to minimize the cost of your debt, this method is for you.
However, it’s important to note that because you’re focusing on the highest-interest debt first, which might also have the largest balance, it could take longer to see any debts fully paid off. This can be challenging if you need the psychological boost of seeing debts disappear.
Debt Snowball Method: A Psychological Boost
The Debt Snowball method, on the other hand, focuses on building momentum by paying off smaller debts first. Here’s how it works:
- List Your Debts by Balance: Organize your debts from the smallest balance to the largest.
- Make Minimum Payments on All Debts: Continue making the minimum payments on all your debts.
- Apply Extra Payments to the Smallest Debt: Any extra money you have goes towards the debt with the smallest balance.
- Move Up the List: Once the smallest debt is paid off, move on to the next smallest, applying extra payments there.
The primary benefit of the Debt Snowball method is the psychological boost it provides. By paying off smaller debts quickly, you get a sense of accomplishment that can keep you motivated to continue.
This method is particularly effective if you’re someone who needs to see progress to stay engaged with your debt repayment plan. However, it’s worth noting that the Debt Snowball method might cost you more in interest over time compared to the Debt Avalanche method, especially if your smallest debts have lower interest rates.
Which Method Is Right for You?
Both the Debt Avalanche and Debt Snowball methods can help you become debt-free, but the best method for you depends on your financial situation and personality.
-
Choose the Debt Avalanche Method if you’re focused on minimizing the total interest paid and you’re disciplined enough to stick with a plan that may take longer to show progress.
-
Choose the Debt Snowball Method if you need quick wins to stay motivated and you’re okay with potentially paying more in interest over time for the psychological benefit.
Remember, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The key is to pick a method that you can stick with and that aligns with your goals and mindset.
Should You Invest First and Just Pay the Minimums?
Another strategy that some people consider is investing first and just paying the minimums on their debt. This approach can be tempting, especially if you’re eager to start building wealth. But it’s important to understand the risks and rewards before making a decision.
If you choose to invest first, your money has more time to grow. As mentioned earlier, the stock market has historically returned an average of 7-10% per year. So, if you’re paying 2-3% of your credit card balance as a minimum payment and the interest rate on your debt is lower than the return you expect from your investments, you could, in theory, come out ahead by investing.
However, this strategy comes with significant risks. The biggest concern is the interest on your debt, especially if it’s high. Paying only the minimum each month means you’re barely chipping away at the principal, and most of your payment is going toward interest. Over time, the interest can snowball, potentially costing you thousands of dollars in the long run.
Another important point is the psychological burden of carrying high-interest debt. According to a study by Northwestern Mutual, people with significant debt are more likely to experience financial stress, which can impact your overall well-being. Even if your investments are growing, the weight of debt can still hold you back, especially if an emergency arises and you need cash quickly.
Employer 401(k) Match: The Game-Changer
One situation where investing might make more sense, even if you have debt, is if your employer offers a match on your 401(k) contributions. This is essentially free money, and it’s one of the best returns you can get on your investment.
Let’s say your employer offers a dollar-for-dollar match up to 4% of your salary. If you earn $50,000 a year and contribute 4% of your salary to your 401(k), that’s $2,000. With the employer match, your contribution instantly doubles to $4,000. That’s $2,000 of free money—money that grows tax-deferred until you retire.
Even if you’re paying off high-interest debt, it usually makes sense to contribute enough to your 401(k) to get the full employer match. The reason is simple—no matter how high your debt interest rate is, it’s unlikely to beat the immediate, guaranteed 100% return you get from your employer match.
Conclusion: What’s Your Next Step?
We’ve covered a lot of ground in this post—from understanding the burden of high-interest debt to finding the right balance between paying off that debt and investing for your future. If there’s one thing you should take away from this, it’s that your financial decisions should always align with your personal goals and comfort level.
Whether you decide to focus on paying off debt first, start investing while managing debt, or find a balance between the two, the most important thing is to have a plan.
If you’re feeling overwhelmed by debt or unsure about how to start investing, or maybe you’re just trying to figure out how to do both effectively, I’m here to help. It’s not about choosing one over the other—it’s about creating a plan that puts you on the path to financial freedom.